Descendants updated and provided by: Colby Duerk
mailto:norrinradd@nyc.rr.com
UNKNOWN SEX & NAME.
CENSUS: 1880 US Census
Household:
Name Relation Marital Status Gender Race Age Birthplace Occupation Father's Birthplace Mother's Birthplace
H. F. CARPENTER Self M Male W 46 MA Physician MA MA
V. Susan CARPENTER Wife M Female W 44 MA Keeping House MA MA
M. Anna CARPENTER Dau S Female W 18 CT Music Teacher MA MA
Source Information:
Census Place Santa Clara, Santa Clara, California
Family History Library Film 1254081
NA Film Number T9-0081
Page Number 230CGRAVE: image
Francis Carpenter
Birth: 7 Apr 1828
Death: 20 Jul 1888
Burial: Perryville CemeteryDudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Memorial #: 50864686
Bio: Age 60 yrs, 3 mos, 13 days
Family Members
Parents
Charles Carpenter 1804-1875
Polly Perry Carpenter 1810-1884
Siblings
Rebekah Carpenter* 1831-1833
Charles Carpenter* 1834-1853
Charles Carpenter* 1835-1853
Mary Jane Carpenter Bailey* 1839-1898
Laura Ann Carpenter Tourtellotte* 1841-1925
Edward Carpenter* 1844-1907
Martha Carpenter Rhodes* 1846-1899
Created by: Suzanne Stewart (47033931)
Added: 9 Apr 2010
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/50864686/francis-carpenter
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Francis Carpenter (7 Apr 1828–20 Jul 1888), Find A Grave Memorial no. 50864686, citing Perryville Cemetery, Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by Suzanne Stewart (contributor 47033931) .
NAME: Mary F. and Mary J. both found.
GRAVE: image
Mary Jane Carpenter Bailey
Birth: 20 Oct 1839 Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Death: 16 Feb 1898 Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA
Burial: Vernon Grove CemeteryMilford, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Memorial #: 144356768
Family Members
Parents
Charles Carpenter 1804-1875
Polly Perry Carpenter 1810-1884
Spouse
Thomas Buckland Bailey* 1832-1906
Siblings
Francis Carpenter* 1828-1888
Rebekah Carpenter* 1831-1833
Charles Carpenter* 1834-1853
Charles Carpenter* 1835-1853
Laura Ann Carpenter Tourtellotte* 1841-1925
Edward Carpenter* 1844-1907
Martha Carpenter Rhodes* 1846-1899
Children
Frederick Irving Bailey* 1859-1897
Arthur Carpenter Bailey* 1863-1864
Jennie Amelia Bailey* 1866-1876
Everett Arthur Bailey* 1870-1876
Thomas Wendell Bailey* 1877-1910
Created by: James Bianco (47745493)
Added: 30 Mar 2015
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/144356768/mary-jane-bailey
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Mary Jane Carpenter Bailey (20 Oct 1839–16 Feb 1898), Find A Grave Memorial no. 144356768, citing Vernon Grove Cemetery, Milford, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by James Bianco (contributor 47745493) .
CENSUS: 1880 US Census
Household:
Name Relation Marital Status Gender Race Age Birthplace Occupation Father's Birthplace Mother's Birthplace
Thomas B. BAILEY Self M Male W 47 MA Druggist MA MA
Mary J. BAILEY Wife M Female W 40 MA Keeping House MA NH
Frederick I. BAILEY Son S Male W 20 MA Clerk In Store MA MA
Thomas W. BAILEY Son S Male W 3 MA MA MA
Polly CARPENTER MotherL W Female W 70 MA At Home MA MA
Leslie G. BELEVEAU Other S Male W 22 NH Clerk In Store NH NH
Lizze T. DACY Other S Female W 18 MA Domestic Servant IREL GREAT BRITAIN
Source Information:
Census Place Milford, Worcester, Massachusetts
Family History Library Film 1254565
NA Film Number T9-0565
Page Number 565BGRAVE: image
Thomas Buckland Bailey
Birth: 12 Aug 1832 Milford, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Death: 2 Jun 1906 Boston, Suffolk County, Massachusetts, USA
Burial: Vernon Grove CemeteryMilford, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Memorial #: 144356765
Bio: son of William & Ann Homer (Tilton) Bailey
Family Members
Parents
William Bailey 1792-1834
Ann Homer Tilton Bailey 1798-1873
Spouse
Mary Jane Carpenter Bailey 1839-1898
Siblings
Daniel M. Bailey* 1828-1834
Children
Frederick Irving Bailey* 1859-1897
Arthur Carpenter Bailey* 1863-1864
Jennie Amelia Bailey* 1866-1876
Everett Arthur Bailey* 1870-1876
Thomas Wendell Bailey* 1877-1910
Created by: James Bianco (47745493)
Added: 30 Mar 2015
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/144356765/thomas-buckland-bailey
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Thomas Buckland Bailey (12 Aug 1832–2 Jun 1906), Find A Grave Memorial no. 144356765, citing Vernon Grove Cemetery, Milford, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by James Bianco (contributor 47745493) .
GRAVE: images
Edward Carpenter
Birth: 1844
Death: 1907
Burial: Perryville CemeteryDudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Memorial #: 50868749
Family Members
Parents
Charles Carpenter 1804-1875
Polly Perry Carpenter 1810-1884
Spouses
Sarah D Batchelder Carpenter 1847-1904
Emma R Barnes Carpenter* 1846-1870
Siblings
Francis Carpenter* 1828-1888
Rebekah Carpenter* 1831-1833
Charles Carpenter* 1834-1853
Charles Carpenter* 1835-1853
Mary Jane Carpenter Bailey* 1839-1898
Laura Ann Carpenter Tourtellotte* 1841-1925
Martha Carpenter Rhodes* 1846-1899
Children
Martha Alice Carpenter Cook* 1870-1950
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney* 1876-1942
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue* 1881-1938
Created by: Suzanne Stewart (47033931)
Added: 9 Apr 2010
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/50868749/edward-carpenter
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Edward Carpenter (1844–1907), Find A Grave Memorial no. 50868749, citing Perryville Cemetery, Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by Suzanne Stewart (contributor 47033931) .
GRAVE: images
Sarah D Batchelder Carpenter
Birth: 27 Jul 1847 Amesbury, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA
Death: 7 Feb 1904 Bridgewater, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Burial: Perryville CemeteryDudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Plot: CARPENTER
Memorial #: 50868948
Family Members
Spouse
Edward Carpenter* 1844-1907
Children
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney* 1876-1942
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue* 1881-1938
Created by: Suzanne Stewart (47033931)
Added: 9 Apr 2010
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/50868948/sarah-d-carpenter
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Sarah D Batchelder Carpenter (27 Jul 1847–7 Feb 1904), Find A Grave Memorial no. 50868948, citing Perryville Cemetery, Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by Suzanne Stewart (contributor 47033931) .
GRAVE: image
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney
Birth: 18 Apr 1876 Glendale, Providence County, Rhode Island, USA
Death: 1942
Burial: Riverside CemeteryWoodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 95361095
Bio: Grace is the daughter of Edward & Sarah Carpenter. She married Arthur B. Pinney on 2 Jan 1901 at Woodstock, VT. (Marriage certificate)
Inscription: His wife."1875 - 1942"
Family Members
Parents
Edward Carpenter 1844-1907
Sarah D Batchelder Carpenter 1847-1904
Spouse
Arthur Bryant Pinney 1865-1919
Siblings
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue* 1881-1938
Half Siblings
Martha Alice Carpenter Cook* 1870-1950
Children
Karen T Pinney* 1904-1977
Created by: David Edsall (46906546)
Added: 14 Aug 2012
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/95361095/grace-mae-pinney
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney (18 Apr 1876–1942), Find A Grave Memorial no. 95361095, citing Riverside Cemetery, Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by David Edsall (contributor 46906546) .
GRAVE: image
Arthur Bryant Pinney
Birth: 5 Dec 1865 Bridgewater, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Death: 5 Jun 1919 Springfield, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Burial: Riverside CemeteryWoodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 95361069
Bio: Arthur is the son of Benton H. Pinney & Mary N. Bryant. He married (1st) Mary J. Dannett on 24 Dec 1891 at Stewartstown, NH. He married (2nd) Grace M. Carpenter on 2 Jan 1901 atWoodstock, VT. (Marriage & Death certificates)
Family Members
Parents
Benton H. Pinney 1839-1920
Minnie Ann Bryant Pinney 1839-1913
Spouse
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney* 1876-1942
Siblings
Burt Lawrence Pinney* 1868-1947
Children
Karen T Pinney* 1904-1977
Created by: David Edsall (46906546)
Added: 14 Aug 2012
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/95361069/arthur-bryant-pinney
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Arthur Bryant Pinney (5 Dec 1865–5 Jun 1919), Find A Grave Memorial no. 95361069, citing Riverside Cemetery, Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by David Edsall (contributor 46906546) .
GRAVE: images
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue
Birth: 11 Aug 1881 Glenham, Dutchess County, New York, USA
Death: 19 Oct 1938
Burial: Westminster West CemeteryWestminster West, Windham County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 116759160
Bio: wife of Ned Goodhue
Family Members
Parents
Edward Carpenter 1844-1907
Sarah D Batchelder Carpenter 1847-1904
Spouse
Ned Dunham Goodhue* 1877-1926
Siblings
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney* 1876-1942
Half Siblings
Martha Alice Carpenter Cook* 1870-1950
Maintained by: Jan Harley (47468145)
Originally Created by: 2patriots (47370354)
Added: 8 Sep 2013
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/116759160/roma-blanche-goodhue
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue (11 Aug 1881–19 Oct 1938), Find A Grave Memorial no. 116759160, citing Westminster West Cemetery, Westminster West, Windham County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by Jan Harley (contributor 47468145) .
GRAVE: images
Dr Ned Dunham Goodhue
Birth: 2 Jul 1877 Putney, Windham County, Vermont, USA
Death: 15 Sep 1926 Dayton, Montgomery County, Ohio, USA
Burial: Westminster West CemeteryWestminster West, Windham County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 116759189
Bio: Education: Cleveland Medical College (Homeopathic), Cleveland, OH. 1903Occupation: PhysicianCause of death: Heart disease
Family Members
Parents
Harlan Goodhue 1847-1933
Mary A Dunham Goodhue 1851-1930
Spouse
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue 1881-1938
Half Siblings
Clifford Goodhue* 1888-1906
Created by: 2patriots (47370354)
Added: 8 Sep 2013
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/116759189/ned-dunham-goodhue
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Dr Ned Dunham Goodhue (2 Jul 1877–15 Sep 1926), Find A Grave Memorial no. 116759189, citing Westminster West Cemetery, Westminster West, Windham County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by 2patriots (contributor 47370354) .
GRAVE: images
Emma R Barnes Carpenter
Birth: 1846 Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Death: 10 Oct 1870 Amesbury, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA
Burial: Perryville CemeteryDudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA
Plot: CARPENTER
Memorial #: 50868995
Family Members
Spouse
Edward Carpenter 1844-1907
Children
Martha Alice Carpenter Cook* 1870-1950
Created by: Suzanne Stewart (47033931)
Added: 9 Apr 2010
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/50868995/emma-r-carpenter
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Emma R Barnes Carpenter (1846–10 Oct 1870), Find A Grave Memorial no. 50868995, citing Perryville Cemetery, Dudley, Worcester County, Massachusetts, USA ; Maintained by Suzanne Stewart (contributor 47033931) .
32173. Martha Alice "Mattie" Carpenter
GRAVE: image
Martha Alice “Mattie” Carpenter Cook
Birth: 9 Jun 1870 Amesbury, Essex County, Massachusetts, USA
Death: 25 Feb 1950 Chittenden, Rutland County, Vermont, USA
Burial: Riverside CemeteryWoodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 132748501
Family Members
Parents
Edward Carpenter 1844-1907
Emma R Barnes Carpenter 1846-1870
Spouses
Ferris Jasper Perkins 1870-1923
Walter Merritt Cook* 1865-1946
Half Siblings
Grace Mae Carpenter Pinney* 1876-1942
Roma Blanche Carpenter Goodhue* 1881-1938
Children
Ray Carpenter Perkins* 1898-1985
Ethel Hudson Perkins Cook* 1902-1960
Created by: Sue (47067682)
Added: 13 Jul 2014
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/132748501/martha-alice-cook
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Martha Alice “Mattie” Carpenter Cook (9 Jun 1870–25 Feb 1950), Find A Grave Memorial no. 132748501, citing Riverside Cemetery, Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by Sue (contributor 47067682) .
GRAVE: image
Ferris Jasper Perkins
Birth: 21 Mar 1870 Bridgewater, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Death: 14 Feb 1923 Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Burial: Riverside CemeteryWoodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA
Memorial #: 132748486
Family Members
Parents
Jasper H Perkins 1838-1912
Jane Hudson Perkins 1840-1923
Spouse
Martha Alice Carpenter Cook* 1870-1950
Children
Ray Carpenter Perkins* 1898-1985
Ethel Hudson Perkins Cook* 1902-1960
Created by: Sue (47067682)
Added: 13 Jul 2014
URL: https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/132748486/ferris-jasper-perkins
Citation: Find A Grave, database and images (https://www.findagrave.com : accessed 05 January 2018), memorial page for Ferris Jasper Perkins (21 Mar 1870–14 Feb 1923), Find A Grave Memorial no. 132748486, citing Riverside Cemetery, Woodstock, Windsor County, Vermont, USA ; Maintained by Sue (contributor 47067682) .
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.See 1850 census Milford, Worc. Co. MA, Page 55
Confused birth locations. Either MA or RI. MA per 1850 Census. Age 13.CENSUS: 1850 US Census - with parents
Name: William H Carpenter
Residence: Milford, Worcester, Massachusetts
Age: 13 years
Calculated Birth Year: 1837
Birthplace: Massachusetts
Gender: Male
Race (original):
Race (expanded):
Death Month:
Death Year:
Film Number: 443563
Digital GS Number: 4181063
Image Number: 00346
Line Number: 1
Dwelling House Number: 635
Family Number: 833
Marital Status:
Free or Slave:
Collection: United States Census, 1850CENSUS: 1880 United States Census
Household:
Name Relation Marital Status Gender Race Age Birthplace Occupation Father's Birthplace Mother's Birthplace
William H. CARPENTER Self M Male W 45 RI Laborer RI RI
Annie S. CARPENTER Wife M Female W 31 MA Keeping House IRE IRE
Hattie N. CARPENTER Dau S Female W 11 MA At School RI MA
Joseph P. CARPENTER Son S Male W 4 MA RI MA
Henry G. CARPENTER Son S Male W 2 MA RI MA
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source Information:
Census Place Ward 5, Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts
Family History Library Film 1254526
NA Film Number T9-0526
Page Number 412BCENSUS: 1900 US Census - see image: RIN 15711 William Harvey Carpenter 1900.jpg
Name: William H Carpenter
Titles:
Residence: Brookline town (east of St. Paul St. & between Longwood & Aspinall Aves.), Norfolk, Massachusetts
Birth Date: Feb 1837
Birthplace: Massachusetts
Relationship to Head-of-Household: Self
Spouse Name: Lizzie M Carpenter
Spouse Titles:
Spouse Birth Place: Massachusetts
Father Name:
Father Titles:
Father Birthplace: Vermont
Mother Name:
Mother Titles:
Mother Birthplace: Rhode Island
Race or Color (expanded): White
Head-of-household Name:
Gender: Male
Marital Status: Married
Years Married: 19
Estimated Marriage Year: 1881
Mother How Many Children:
Number Living Children:
Immigration Year:
Enumeration District: 1018
Sheet Number and Letter: 5B
Household ID: 99
Reference Number: 87
GSU Film Number: 1240669
Image Number: 00000068
Collection: United States Census, 1900DEATH:
Name: William Henry Carpenter
Titles & Terms:
Event: Death
Event Date: 23 Jul 1914
Event Place: Brookline,,Massachusetts
Residence:
Street Address:
Gender: Male
Age: 77
Marital Status: Married
Occupation:
Birth Date: 21 Feb 1837
Birthplace: Uxbridge, Massachusetts
Estimated Birth Year:
Burial Date:
Burial Place:
Cemetery:
Father: Joseph Carpenter
Father's Titles & Terms:
Father's Birthplace:
Mother:
Mother's Titles & Terms:
Mother's Birthplace:
Additional Relatives:
Spouse:
Volume/Page/Certificate Number: 109
Film Number: 2404109
Frame Number:
Digital Folder Number: 4284189
Image Number: 01155
Source Citation
"Massachusetts, Deaths, 1841-1915," index and images, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/N4WB-8BN : accessed 10 Sep 2012), William Henry Carpenter, 1914.
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.See 1850 census, VR page 41
Two children are listed born in the same year in the above record by
Charles A. Carpenter. However, source listed only lists one child.
This child (Baby) must be Charles.
CENSUS:
1880 United States Census
Household:
Name Relation Marital Status Gender Race Age Birthplace Occupation Father's Birthplace Mother's Birthplace
Hannah E. LINCOLN Self W Female W 56 ME Keeping House ME ME
Herbert LINCOLN Son S Male W 23 MA Tinsmith MA ME
Nelly CARPENTER Other W Female W 35 MA Dressmaker MA MA
Bella CARPENTER Other S Female W 10 MA At School MA MA
Hatty F. SAUNDERS Other S Female W 40 ME Housekeeper ME ME
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Source Information:
Census Place Taunton, Bristol, Massachusetts
Family History Library Film 1254526
NA Film Number T9-0526
Page Number 397B
23681. Frank Aldrich Carpenter
BIRTH: Parents registerd his birth, RI Book 53, p.308 Greenfield/Smithfield,
RI.
MARR: Providence Marriage Records 12:259.
DEATH: Point Judith, RI "1938 Hurricane" - Cause of death lists;
Tidal Wave and Huricane. Providence, RI, book 78, page 922. See also
Central Falls VR 1:1.Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.SOURCE: Central FAlls VR 1:1; RI Bk.58, pg. 308; Uxbridge, Ma. VR to the
year 1850. Death rec. RI VR #337; death cert.NOTE: This Frank Carpenter has been confused with the Frank Carpenter born
20 Dec. 1857 in the same area. Allegedly they married the same person and had
the same children.
BIRTH: MA Birth records 125:180.
DEATH:Providence, RI Death Records 17:259
!MARRIAGE: Two (2) Frank Carpenters are listed. See their notes.
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.SOURCE: Ma. births 125:180. Rov. RI marriages 12:172 Bk 78, pg. 922. death
Prov. RI 17:259.
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.
DEATH:North Burial Ground Records.
23682. George Daniel Carpenter
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.MARRIAGE2:
Name: George D. Carpenter
Titles and Terms:
Event Type: Marriage
Event Date: 17 Oct 1881
Event Place: Kane, Illinois, United States
Age: 26
Birth Year (Estimated): 1855
Father's Name: Daniel G. Carpenter
Father's Titles and Terms:
Mother's Name: Mary Maine
Mother's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Name: Josephine Baltazare Martin
Spouse's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Age: 20
Spouse's Birth Year (Estimated): 1861
Spouse's Father's Name: Levie Baltazare
Spouse's Father's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Mother's Name: Sophia Desotal
Spouse's Mother's Titles and Terms:
Reference ID: 1500
GS Film number: 1480743
Digital Folder Number: 004708098
Image Number: 01659
Citing this Record:
"Illinois, County Marriages, 1810-1934," index, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/KF2Q-T9B : accessed 04 Aug 2013), George D. Carpenter and Josephine Baltazare Martin, 1881.
SEE ALSO:
Name: George D. Carpenter
Titles and Terms:
Event Type: Marriage
Event Date: 17 Oct 1881
Event Place: Kane, Illinois, United States
Age: 26
Birth Year (Estimated): 1855
Father's Name: Daniel G. Carpenter
Father's Titles and Terms:
Mother's Name: Mary Maine
Mother's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Name: Josephine Baltarne
Spouse's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Age: 19
Spouse's Birth Year (Estimated): 1862
Spouse's Father's Name: L. Baltarne
Spouse's Father's Titles and Terms:
Spouse's Mother's Name: Sophia Desotel
Spouse's Mother's Titles and Terms:
Reference ID:
GS Film number: 1481108
Digital Folder Number: 005205846
Image Number: 00723
Citing this Record:
"Illinois, County Marriages, 1810-1934," index, FamilySearch (https://familysearch.org/pal:/MM9.1.1/KFLL-D73 : accessed 04 Aug 2013), George D. Carpenter and Josephine Baltarne, 1881.
Information supplied on this line by:
Charles A. Carpenter (b. 1947) of St. Cloud, FL.
It is possible that this marriage is a mixup of "Charles".
The Carpenter Memorial indicates this Charles as being born in 1889, after the father's death date. 1879 would be more reasonable. Questions remain.