Descendants of Group 5 - Zimmermans / Carpenters
Why are Haplogroups and Big Y testing so important to Group 5?
By Bob Carpenter, Group Leader
5 Jan 2025
Introduction
• Y-STRs (aka Y-Chromosome-Short Term Repeats from Y-DNA testing) and Y-SNPs (aka Y-Chromosome Single Nucleotide Polymorphism - pronounced Y-Snip) form two types of Y-DNA testing for researching surnames. It is very important to understand the purpose of each as they are quite different from one another. Failure to do so can lead to misinterpretation of Y-STR matches.
• Cross Validation by using multiple types of markers can enhance the reliability of genealogical conclusions. Y-STRs can validate Y-SNP test results and vice versa.
• It is most helpful to collaborate with other tested members to build a comprehensive family tree and identify sub-haplogroups within the surname lineage.
• Genetic test results provide the possibility of verifying the biological versus the legal genealogy of an individual, which cannot be verified using only written records.
• The Big Y-700 test brings testing from just one of many tools to one of the premier tools for genealogists studying paternal lineages.
Y-STRs - Y-chromosome - Short Tandem Repeats
• Y-STRs are inherited unchanged (except for mutations) along the paternal line, allowing genealogists to identify relationships between males who share a recent common ancestor.
• Y-STRs provide a high-resolution tool for analyzing recent paternal ancestry and distinguishing between closely related male lineages.
• Y-STRs mutate at a relatively fast rate, more frequently than Y-SNPs making them ideal for tracing recent paternal ancestry and distinguishing between closely-related male lineages. It is very difficult to identify a ‘back mutation’ or a ‘parallel mutation’, and as a result we don’t know how often they occur.
• Back mutation: a mutation reverts back to its previous value. For example, a STR mutates from 6 to 7. Three generations later it mutates back to 6, returning to its modal value. This in effect is saying that no mutation has recently occurred at that location.
• Parallel mutation: two different branches separately descend from the same common ancestor by mutating the same way at different time intervals.
• Y-STR modal values are essential for establishing broad connections and ancestral haplotypes within a family or haplogroup. Non-modal values are key for differentiating between individuals within that lineage, estimating genetic distance, and identifying more recent branches of the family tree.
• Y-STR non-modal values are especially important in identifying recent ancestry as they can signal a unique branch or sub-haplogroup within a family. See CCG5's Mutation History Tree.
• Y-STR convergence occurs when unrelated paternal lineages share identical Y-STR marker values, making it challenging to distinguish between them based solely on Y-STR results. If convergence is a possibility it is recommended that you upgrade to a minimum of 67-markers.
• Y-STRs in combination with Y-SNPs provide a more comprehensive timeline and context, enabling one to differentiate between ancient and modern connections with greater clarity.
Haplotype
• The first objective in Y-STR surname group testing is to find common haplotypes which lead to matching lineage branches.
• A haplotype is a cluster of Y-STR allele results inherited from your father. They represent a critical genetic signature and a tool for genetic genealogy, enabling researchers to confirm relationships, calculate genetic distance, and participate in surname or lineage studies.
• The primary object of triangulation is to determine the generation in which the mutation occurred and the haplotype of the corresponding common ancestor.
• Y-DNA haplotypes are a unique genetic signature that can be compared with other individuals’ haplotypes to assess relatedness and ancestry.
Y-SNPs - Y-chromosome - Single Nucleotide Polymorphisms
• A SNP represents a change to a single nucleotide in a DNA sequence, having an extremely low mutation rate and providing a more definitive resolution in paternal lineages.
• SNPs define and trace deep paternal ancestry, providing a stable and reliable framework for constructing the Y-DNA haplotree and mapping ancient migrations.
• SNPs can also refute relationships presented by Y-STR matches and reduce false positives in genetic genealogical research. They also complement Y-STRs by offering long-term lineage markers.
• Y-SNPs can identify where a lineage split occurred in the distant past, allowing genealogists to connect their lineage to known historical or prehistoric populations.
• Y-SNPs help refine the relationship estimates between individuals by placing them within specific branches of the Y-chromosome phylogenetic tree. They also help to identify common ancestors within a specific genealogical time frame, which is crucial for identifying additional branches on the family tree.
• Y-SNPs that originate in the genealogical time frame are more important as they define new branches. These new branches are in addition to the already defined branches that provide information on how the branches are connected and the relative time frame for each branch.
• Y-SNPs are crucial for constructing haplogroups and sub-haplogroups (subclades), which represent lineages and their evolutionary relationships over tens of thousands of years.
• It is important to test strategically. This is accomplished by focusing testing efforts on those cousin members whose genetic information will be most relevant to your genealogy!
Y-UEPs - Y-chromosome - Unique Event Polymorphisms
• UEPs provide stable, irreversible genetic markers for defining and tracing paternal lineages over a long evolutionary time scale. They are inherited from the same common ancestor and are foundational for the construction of the Y-DNA haplotree.
• UEPs correspond to a mutation that is likely to occur so infrequently that it is believed overwhelmingly probable that all the individuals who share the marker are related. UEPs, such as SNPs, InDels-(Insertions & Deletions), and irreversible mutations, are used to establish the structure of the Y-DNA haplotree and to trace deep paternal ancestry. FamilyTreeDNA designates Y-SNP ‘I-FTC10836' for Group 5 as a Deletion.
Y-chromosome Haplogroups
• The primary purpose of Y-DNA haplogroups is to provide a framework for understanding the deep paternal ancestry of an individual.
• Haplogroups represent branches on the human Y-chromosome phylogenetic tree and are defined by specific Y-SNP mutations that occur at various points in human evolutionary history.
• A haplogroup represents a cluster of testers who share the same UEP, which is a distinctive Y-SNP inherited from their father.
• Haplogroups define specific mutations in the non-recombining portions of DNA on the male-specific Y chromosome (Y-DNA).
• Haplogroups are the genetic signature of our ancient ancestors. They trace your paternal line (father to son) and provide clues about where your family originated years ago.
• Haplogroups and sub-haplogroups are crucial for paternal genealogy research.
• Haplogroups not only help trace paternal lineage and ancestral origins, they also enhance the accuracy and depth of genealogical research.
• Sub-haplogroups are mutations that differentiate your family from others in the same haplogroup.
• The more closely you resemble a model haplotype, the more confident you can be about your haplogroup.
• FamilyTreeDNA’s Big Y-700 is the only Y-DNA test that can provide you with a full haplogroup. It also tests for known Y-SNPs and discovers new Y-SNPs that are unique to your direct paternal line.
• To support or reject a hypothesized relationship, a Y-SNP test of a proven direct-line paternal descendant will provide evidence to support or reject this hypothesis based solely on the haplogroup.
• The key differentiator of Carpenter Cousins Group 5's Haplogroup is that all members who have received their Big Y-700 test results are from one branch of the Y-DNA Haplotree and share the Progenitor of Y-SNP I-A10757 as their common ancestor.
Seven Pros and Cons of Y-SNP Testing
1) If the primary goal is to confirm a close paternal relationship (e.g., father-son or siblings), Y-STR testing is usually sufficient, and may not add immediate value.
2) Y-SNPs allow for the identification of specific sub-branches within a haplogroup, providing a finer resolution of ancestry compared to Y-STRs alone.
3) When Y-STR results are ambiguous or conflicting, SNP testing can provide definitive evidence to confirm relationships or rule them out. Y-STRs can become ambiguous due to convergence issues, i.e., backward and parallel mutations.
4) Y-SNP testing and haplogroup analysis can significantly enhance genealogical research by providing more precise lineage information, resolving ambiguities, and connecting deep ancestry with historical contexts.
5) While not every genealogical study requires SNP testing, dismissing its value outright overlooks its substantial contributions to both traditional and genetic genealogy.
6) Some researchers may feel SNP tests are unnecessary if they are focused solely on recent genealogy, but this view underestimates the long-term value of refining the haplogroup structure.
7) While SNP tests can be more expensive than Y-STR tests, their contribution to refining haplogroups and confirming lineages often justifies the cost, especially for advanced research or when traditional genealogical records are not available.
Surname List | Name Index
Return to the main start page